A Cold Coming
The poem combines the images of war with the idea of death because death is a consequence of war, and is what the "charred" soldier is experiencing in the poem. The images of war and birth are combined because the American soldiers save their sperm in sperm banks so that in the case they should die at war, their wives might still be able to conceive their child.
The author focuses on the idea of procreation and sperm banks as they portray the atrocities and ghastly aspects of war. The soldiers use these sperm banks in the case they should no trutrn from the war. Is it right or wrong to still have the child of a deceased husband? The child would not have a father and might be a constant reminder to the wife of her husband.
It is important that the Iraqui solder is talking to a poet instead of a journalist because the poet can change the words to less gruesome and possibly less vivid, whereas a journalist writes facts, quote for quote. Speaking to a poet would probably be more beneficial to the readers, so they don't have to know all the details of what the soldier is experiencing in the war.
The author focuses on the idea of procreation and sperm banks as they portray the atrocities and ghastly aspects of war. The soldiers use these sperm banks in the case they should no trutrn from the war. Is it right or wrong to still have the child of a deceased husband? The child would not have a father and might be a constant reminder to the wife of her husband.
It is important that the Iraqui solder is talking to a poet instead of a journalist because the poet can change the words to less gruesome and possibly less vivid, whereas a journalist writes facts, quote for quote. Speaking to a poet would probably be more beneficial to the readers, so they don't have to know all the details of what the soldier is experiencing in the war.
6 Comments:
I like your analysis of A Cold Coming. I never thought about the children that would be born from these sperm banks. It would be interesting to see what the soldiers would say about their children that may be born fatherless.
By
Meghan, At
April 23, 2008 at 10:06 AM
That is the same idea I had in mind about the author's position. War is all about killing or get killed.
By
maurice, At
April 23, 2008 at 3:54 PM
I like how you included a note about the children that might be born from the sperm banks. I didn't tink of this when i read the story.
By
Patrick's Blog, At
April 23, 2008 at 8:10 PM
You bring up a very good point about the child being born even though the dad has already died. First of all it just seems to wierd and sperm banks all together are weird but, It doesn't seem like anybody would be able to have a child from sperm from a deceased father.
By
Brad Dimock, At
April 23, 2008 at 9:27 PM
I liked the reference you made about the dying soldier with "charred," referencing how the soldier is. Also, about life and death, I think it would be interesting to see what would happen to the fatherless children as well.
By
Lindsay, At
April 24, 2008 at 6:34 AM
I like how you focused on the fact that war is really macabre.
By
DW, At
April 29, 2008 at 12:49 PM
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home